Skip to content

Visiting judges from Estonia evaluate judicial programs | News

PRINCETON — Six courtroom judges from Estonia have spent this week in Mercer County, seeing first-hand how the judicial system works right here in addition to assembly with county, metropolis and state officers.

Estonia, a small nation with a inhabitants of 1.3 million, is situated in Eastern Europe north of Poland on the Baltic Sea and the Gulf of Finland, bordered by Russia to the east and Latvia to the south.

The nation has been within the information this yr as a result of it was one of many nations below the rule of the Soviet Union till gaining independence in 1989 with the collapse of the Soviet Union, a topic the group mentioned this week. But the principle focus was on the comparability of judicial programs and their experiences right here.

The delegation is right here by way of a Congressional Office for International Leadership (previously often known as the Open World Leadership Center) program to advertise worldwide relationships.

Members of the delegation are Mr. Erkki Hirsnik, Criminal Law, Appeals Court; Ms. Triin Harak, County Court; Mr. Janar Jaatma, Administrative Law, Circuit Court; Ms. Mari-Liis Avikson, County Court; Ms. Ragne Piir, Administrative Court; and Assistant Prosecutor Ms. Laura Jogisoo.

On Tuesday, the group mentioned their experiences right here whereas they have been ready to attend a courtroom continuing in Mercer County Circuit Court Judge William Sadler’s courtoom.

Although the judicial programs are related, there are few variations.

“The most important distinction in my eyes is the jury,” Hirsnik stated. “We don’t have it. The closing choice is at all times made by an expert choose — usually by him/her alone or typically with two lay judges.”

Hirsnik stated grand juries are usually not used both.

“It’s as much as the prosecutor to determine whether or not a case ought to be introduced in entrance of the choose or not ,” he stated.

Another distinction is how the judges work together with the events concerned in courtroom.

“I believe they’re extra open than in Estonia — they communicate to events extra within the U.S. than they do in Estonia,” stated, including the judges nonetheless stay “very skilled.”

Piir stated she discovered watching the usage of a jury fascinating.

“I’d say that broadly talking and at a primary look, courtroom proceedings — not less than so far as a bench trial is anxious — don’t differ that a lot within the U.S. and Estonia,” she stated. “Jury trial is an entire totally different matter and was very fascinating to watch right here within the U.S. since we don’t have that in Estonia. We additionally do not need magistrates or Justice of the Peace courts.”

Hirsnik stated one similarity that stood out is in questioning witnesses.

“I used to be impressed with the cross examination of witnesses,” he stated. “It may be very very similar to at dwelling.”

Hirsnik stated plea bargaining is far the identical as nicely.

One different massive distinction within the system is Estonia doesn’t have household courts.

However, Harak stated she likes the thought of a household courtroom due to the privateness difficulty however just isn’t positive if that can ever be a part of their judicial system.

Punishments are related, Hirsnik stated, however the nation has solely 2,500 individuals incarcerated.

Capital punishment just isn’t an choice since it’s banned in all European Union (EU) nations, which Estonia is a part of.

Jogisoo is a prosecutor and analyzed the courtroom from that perspective.

“After seeing one jury listening to I’d say that in our basic proceedings the prosecutor has a really related demeanor and method,” she stated. “We additionally should make opening statements, introduce proof, cross-examine and provides closing arguments. When we speak about pre-trial proceedings, then our prosecutors even have the chance to participate of the investigation themselves, equivalent to take statements, ask for extra data and so on.”

The forms of crimes have some similarities, however only a few homicide circumstances are seen.

“Our homicide fee if very, very low,” Harak stated.

Hirsnik stated gun possession just isn’t widespread in Estonia, and most crimes are drunk driving, home violence, theft and the nation does have points with medicine, however not on a big scale.

Harak stated that’s as a result of pharmacies are extremely regulated, and docs are required to make use of a strict course of in prescribing addictive medicine, assembly a number of standards to ensure it’s needed.

Judges have rather a lot accountability in Estonia however Piir stated they’re ready.

“All of our judges should have a authorized training of 5 years and prior authorized work expertise,” she stated, in addition to meet different standards.

Hirsnik stated politics just isn’t concerned in changing into a choose, that it’s like making use of for an expert job with a sequence of necessities to qualify.

“In order to turn out to be a choose you need to take extra exams and an internship,” he stated. “There is an entire course of to undergo.”

Judges are additionally educated to have the ability to deal with circumstances in all different courts as nicely, not simply their specialty.

Harak stated a choose can’t belong to a political occasion and no choose is elected.

The system in Estonia just isn’t sophisticated, she stated, with the county courts (much like basic courtroom right here), administrative courts, circuit courts and one central supreme courtroom for the nation.

“Each county has its personal courts with just one supreme courtroom since we now have no states,” she stated.

Most circumstances undergo the system comparatively rapidly, Hirsnik stated, however extra sophisticated circumstances, simply as within the U.S., can take years.

“Estonia is within the high 3 in Europe so far as the effectivity of the courtroom proceedings is anxious,” Piir stated. “I simply checked the 2022 European Union Justice Scoreboard and based on that, Estonia holds the 2nd place (after Denmark) relating to the pace of courtroom proceedings. The estimated time to resolve a civil case in Estonia is 101 days, for an administrative case it stands at 127 days and for a prison offense (not a misdemeanor) — 246 days.”

Piir stated it was fascinating to see how courtroom paperwork in West Virginia have been digitalized, a challenge Estonia began years in the past.

“Estonia has additionally put plenty of effort into making justice programs digital over the previous 15 years and so far as I do know, we’re some of the superior nations on this planet for utilizing ICT-solutions for the administration of courts, in addition to communication between courts and different events.,” she stated. “We have an e-File system that enables all communication with and between the events digital. With an digital signature, events can file complaints on-line within the e-File system.”

Of course, the delegation is visiting a spot with a a lot totally different topography. Estonia is flat with the Baltic sea to the west and the Gulf of Finland to the north.

“For us Estonians, it’s very nice to see stunning mountains coated with greenery,” Jogisoo stated. “We don’t have any mountains and those that I’ve seen in Europe are usually not so inexperienced, however extra rocky. So it was a really stunning sight to see after we have been touchdown on the airport.”

Jogisoo additionally stated the life right here appear to be about identical and he or she has been impressed with residents.

“The individuals right here who we now have met are the warmest and most hospitable,” she stated.

That sentiment was echoed by Hirsnik, who stated everybody has been “fantastic.”

All of the judges communicate fluent English and Piir, who can be fluent in French, German and a few Russian, stated the research of different languages begins early.

“It is true that languages are emphasised in early college years (since Estonian is among the world’s smallest official nationwide languages — solely about 1.1 million individuals communicate Estonian as in comparison with 360 million English native audio system),” she stated. “It is compulsory to study two overseas languages at college however these are usually not prescribed by the state. English is often taught as the primary overseas language, beginning largely at 8 or 9 years outdated (it varies a bit of in numerous faculties). The second overseas language can often be chosen between German, French and Russian, some faculties additionally supply Spanish, Finnish or Swedish. It just isn’t unusual to study a 3rd overseas language at college, though non-compulsory.”

One subject all of the judges adamantly agreed on was the independence of their nation, expressing deep concern about what Russia will do after invading Ukraine.

“We are a member of NATO,” Hirsnik stated. “But there may be worry of what Russia could do.”

About 25 p.c of the inhabitants of Estonia are Russian, he added, a results of the post-World War II occupation, however there isn’t any organized pro-Russian group contained in the nation as is the case in Eastern Ukraine.

Harak stated she thinks NATO has grown stronger due to Russian’s actions on Ukraine and that does supply a stage of safety, particularly since Sweden and Finland are set to affix. Finland is a brief distance to the north of Estonia.

“But everyone seems to be afraid,” she stated.

Hirsnik had excessive reward for Ukraine and stated, opposite to what media usually say, it’s not “Putin’s struggle.”

“It is the Russians’ struggle,” he stated. “They help Putin.”

The delegation is being hosted this week by the Princeton-based Center for International Understanding, Inc. and residential keep hosts Linda and Larry Bray, John and Betse Feuchtenberger, and state Sen. Chandler Swope.

Swope stated it has been a gratifying expertise.

“The complete group are fantastic individuals and I’ve totally loved spending time with all of them,” he stated. “Their English is best than mine.”

He stated Estonia is almost the identical measurement of West Virginia with an identical inhabitants.

“I’ve been collaborating for a few years with this system bringing individuals from many nations to get to know one another and study from one another,” Swope stated. “There might be no higher training than attending to know individuals from all over the world. This group from Estonia are a few of the nicest, friendliest and most clever I’ve met within the final thirty years. I’m very fortunate for the privilege of attending to know them.”

Besides spending time within the Mercer County courtrooms and assembly with varied courtroom workplaces, the group witnessed bench trials within the U.S. Federal Court in Bluefield and met with Mercer County Commissioners, Bluefield City Court and Police Department and the Bluefield City Manager’s Office.

The delegation was additionally scheduled to spend a day in Charleston to fulfill with chosen members of the WV Supreme Court of Appeals and the newly created Intermediate Court of Appeals in addition to the Clerk of the House of Delegates, the West Virginia Bar Association and the ACLU.

The Estonians will conclude their go to in Tazewell the place they’ll study in regards to the variations within the legal guidelines of Virginia and West Virginia from Judge Chip Hurley of Tazewell Circuit Court, twenty ninth Judicial Circuit of Virginia, adopted by dialogs with Tazewell County Administrator on the separation of powers.

— Contact Charles Boothe at

#Visiting #judges #Estonia #evaluate #judicial #programs #News

Leave a Reply